Why Hands-On Chemistry Experiments Can’t Simulate A Prebiotic Earth (Ep. 4)
Stephen Meyer 🕊️ 36K subscribers Aug 23, 2023
When scientists claim they have simulated early earth chemistry to create life from non-life, are they being honest? Enjoy the fourth and final installment in a series of conversations between philosopher of science Dr. Stephen Meyer, author of
Signature in the Cell: DNA and the Evidence for Intelligent Design, and
👨🔬🔬 @DrJamesTour 🕊️, a
world-leading synthetic organic chemist at Rice University.
In Part 4, Meyer and Tour evaluate the work of chemist Bruce Lipshutz; specifically his work designing surfactant molecules that enable amide/peptide bonds. By itself, Lipshutz’s work developing synthetic techniques for doing chemistry in water is interesting and has value. But for those tempted to think that his work validates chemical evolutionary theories of the origin of life, Tour has bad news. Peptides don’t form in aqueous environments like water. A realistic prebiotic environment would not be capable of producing the reactions necessary to form proteins. And Lipshutz acknowledges this. In their conversation, Tour and Meyer discuss how Lipshutz applies hands-on chemistry that bears no resemblance to the likely conditions of a prebiotic earth. If anything, the work of Lipshutz and others in origin of life research is actually simulating the need for intelligent agency to move simple chemicals in a life-friendly direction.
Says Meyer, “Even the modest movement they get towards life seems to be intelligently designed at each step of the way, and even the vocabulary will sometimes reveal that: ribozyme engineer, designer surfactants. Very curious!”CONTEXT
These videos were recorded in Nov and Dec 2022. Dr. Tour has recently been engaged in a series of back-and-forth responses to attacks on his work from YouTube science communicator Dave Farina. This has given Tour a new opportunity to critique experts in the field of abiogenesis and allows an interested public to better evaluate both sides of the argument.
Philosopher of science Dr. Stephen Meyer hosts these engaging conversations. Meyer is author of the 2009 book Signature in the Cell: DNA and the Evidence for Intelligent Design, which explores theories attempting to explain the origin of the first life. So Meyer is the perfect candidate to unpack Tour’s expertise and draw out key insights.
MORE RESOURCES
Dr. James Tour’s lecture at the 2019 Dallas Science & Faith Conference: The Mystery of the Origin of Life
• James Tour: The Mystery of the Origin...
Dr. Tour’s video series: Addressing Abiogenesis (Season 1)
• Addressing Abiogenesis: Season 1
Dr. Tour’s video series continues: Addressing Abiogenesis (Season 2)
• Addressing Abiogenesis: Season 02
Video edited by Eric Herron, Philosopher Films.
======================================================
This is the official Youtube page of Dr. Stephen Meyer, director of Discovery Institute's Center for Science & Culture. Meyer received his Ph.D. in the philosophy of science from the University of Cambridge. His latest book is Return of the God Hypothesis: Three Scientific Discoveries that Reveal the Mind Behind the Universe (2021), see
https://returnofthegodhypothesis.com/.
Meyer is also the author of The New York Times best selling book Darwin's Doubt: The Explosive Origin of Animal Life and the case for Intelligent Design (HarperOne, 2013), and Signature In The Cell: DNA and the Evidence for Intelligent Design (2009). For more information about Dr. Meyer, his research, and his books visit
https://stephencmeyer.org/.
The CSC is the institutional hub for scientists, educators, and inquiring minds who think that nature supplies compelling evidence of intelligent design. The CSC supports research, sponsors educational programs, defends free speech, and produce articles, books, and multimedia content.
Visit other YouTube channels connected to the Center for Science & Culture
Discovery Institute:
/ discoveryinstitute
The Magician's Twin - CS Lewis & Evolution:
/ cslewisweb
Darwin's Heretic - Alfred Russel Wallce:
/ alfredrwallaceid
For more information visit
--
https://www.discovery.org/id/--
http://www.evolutionnews.org/--
http://www.intelligentdesign.org/Follow the CSC on Facebook and Twitter:
Twitter: @discoverycsc
Facebook:
https://www.facebook.com/discoverycsc/