It Is Time to Rethink Red Sea Convoys! |
The
Houthis
Have Diverted 2 Out Of 3 Ships Around Africa What is Going on With Shipping? 299K subscribers Jun 14, 2024 #supplychain #houth #redsea
Red Sea Convoys
In this episode, Sal Mercogliano - a maritime historian at Campbell University (@campbelledu) and former merchant mariner - discusses the latest Houthi attack against MV Tutor using an Unmanned Surface Vessel and killing a merchant mariner onboard (the fourth mariner killed

since the start of the attacks in November 2023

). Should the world navies adopt a new strategy and utilize convoys

to run ships through the Red Sea, Bab el-Mandeb, and the Gulf of Aden?

#supplychain #houth #redsea #shipping #navies #gulfofaden #babelmandeb
Support What's Going on With Shipping via:
Patreon:
www.patreon.com/wgowshipping Twitter: @mercoglianos
Facebook: @wgowshipping
Email: mercoglianosal@gmail.com
00:00 Introduction 
02:21 Shipping Situation 
15:23 New Convoy Operation 
Bulk Carrier Flooding After Surface Drone Attack in Red Sea
A bulk carrier transiting the Panama Canal took out the railroad bridge in Gamboa on Tuesday, causing major damage. The Panama Canal Authority said it is investigating the accident and...
...
UPDATED: Seafarer killed in Houthi attack
<p>The strike on Tutor yesterday left the ship unable to manoeuvre, with one death onboard the vessel now confirmed </p>
...
United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS)
https://www.un.org/depts/los/conventi...
Drewry's Container Index
https://www.drewry.co.uk/supply-chain...
Marine Traffic
www.marinetraffic.com
AGelbert COMMENT: It took a while, but Dr. Sal finally figured out that ya can't stop them Houthis, PERIOD.
Now the good Dr. Sal does NOT want to talk about "politics", but there is NO WAY you can address the RISING COST of shipping insurance without pointing the CAUSE finger at Blinken - Netanyahu et al, period, full stop.
And by the way, when you bemoan FOUR mariner deaths, while studiously ignoring about FORTY THOUSAND DEATHS AND over 70,000 INJURED in Gaza by US bombs, thanks to Netanyahu - Blinken et al, you are guilty of faulty, reasoning (i.e. world class cherry picking), to put it mildly.
And YEAH, you ARE deliberately ignoring the horrors WE AMERICANS are supporting, so do not pretend you can claim an ethical position.
As to who's PROSPERITY is ACTUALLY being guarded, YEAH, I certainly agree with you that it sure ain't the shippers! The fact that you cannot bring yourself to point the finger at NETANYAHU et al smacks of hypocrisy.
All that said, your suggestion that maybe we should just pull the (sitting ducks) US Navy out of there is the proper one.
However, your desire for convoys is so WWII yesterday (i.e. obsolete). WHY? Ships are ALL sitting ducks now, no matter how well armed they are, ever since drone missile robots made blue water navies OBSOLETE. Talk to former CIA Larry Johnson and/or retired Col. Lawrence Wilkerson (Colin Powell State Department). They will explain to you why PEACE, not your idea, is the only cost effective rational answer to the Red Sea Houthi problem.
You like to talk about costs. WHY don't you talk about he COST of missiles on a U.S. warship versus the relatively INSIGNIFICANT costs of drone missles that can be shot at them by the hundreds!
Do you know what it COSTS (millions of DOLLARS!) every time a warship has to rearm with missiles after they have used those onboard to interdict cheap drone cruise missiles?
Remember that, unlike during WWII, when tender ships sailed to warships to rearm them with munitions at sea, there are NO tenders to bring replacement missiles to them at sea now and warships have to go to some secure port, never mind the COST of getting the missiles to the port.
Hey brother American taxpayer, isn't the MASSIVE Pentagon swag now impoverisihng we-the-taxpayers enough for you? You want to spend BILLIONS of ADDITIONAL dollars of our tax money to build convoy warships? WHY do you ignore THAT COST while claiming you "just want to lower shipping costs"?
Dr. Sal, you love shipping, but the U.S. Blue Ocean Navy power projection is NOT WORKING because Blue Ocean Navy warships, whether they be ours, Russia's or China's, constantly exposed to the danger of being sunk by CHEAP, NUMEROUS multiple drone attacks, are all now sitting ducks.
And please spare us the lecture about the Houthi's "not having any right to attack shipping", while ignoring the FACT that WE HAVE NO RIGHT to support the Gaza (see: et al, etc. above).
PEACE is the only rational alternative. Our massive military budget is at least 4 times the size it should be, and even at 25% of the present size, it would STILL be MUCH greater than China's or Russia's military spending COMBINED! I am not asking you to give the Houthis the Nobel Prize for Peace, but they certainly deserve one if their principled actions convince the U.S. to bring PEACE to the Palestinians.